Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs. Lyocell vs. Organic Cotton

When sustainable fashion first burst onto the scene, we were introduced to a number of “eco-friendly” fabrics, such as organic cotton, tencel, and bamboo. Each carried sustainable properties, whether that meant being free of pesticides or fertilizers, produced in a closed-loop system, or made from durable and renewable materials. Here is our Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs. Lyocell vs. Organic Cotton.

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton 2Photo/Unspalsh

There are many environmental implications to consider when doing a comparison, including the use of toxic chemicals and water.

At first, BAMBOO fabric made a lot of sense. Bamboo is one of the fastest growing plants on earth, with one species recorded growing three feet in a single day. Bamboo does not use or rely on chemicals, fertilizers or insecticides to grow. And it requires little water, unlike conventional cotton.

In comparison to cotton, bamboo is known to improve watersheds, purify air quality, and remove toxins from contaminated soil, all with less water consumption and no harmful environmental impact. Bamboo is often planted to prevent soil erosion, it can absorb up to 12 tons of carbon dioxide per hectare and it produces 30% more oxygen than any hardwood forest of similar size. It can also be selectively harvested annually, and it naturally regenerates without replanting.

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton

Photo/Unspalsh

Bamboo may seem like a miracle fibre. In addition, it is soft, affordable, it saves water and is free from pesticides. However, it is transforming it from the plant into a fabric that’s the more complicated issue.

The viscose process is the name of the method used for the transformation of the bamboo fiber. Hence the name “Viscose from Bamboo”. This process includes the dissolution and extrusion. To dissolve the wood, it is necessary to use water and solvent. As we know, water is a very valuable resource in this world. The problem is we do not really know how water is used in the viscose process. Perhaps responsibly, but maybe not. There is no guarantee or certification for this.

Not to mention the corrosive solvents such as sodium hydroxide and carbon disulfide, used to alter the genetic structure of natural bamboo, and turn it into a rayon. While no residue remains in the fiber after the procedure, if the effluent was not disposed of responsibly, or cleaned and reused (closed-loop) it can lead to soil and water contamination. Still, it is not as harmful as the 25% of the world’s pesticides that are dumped directly into the environment to grow conventional cotton!

But it isn’t great, so we either need to find a substitute or use it without damage to the environment.

An example of a Canadian brand that uses closed-loop bamboo, look no further than Miik. Their fabric is custom milled at a weight that provides a rich luxurious drape and offers additional coverage, and is more durable – so it will last you for years!

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton

Photo/Miik

You may have noticed on your clothing labels (for those of you who check!) the fabric TENCEL®. This fabric has undergone the Lyocell process, which is the name of the transformation process that changes wood into textile fiber. TENCEL® is the name of the fiber developed by Lenzing whose raw material comes from eucalyptus and is processed according to the lyocell process, which is a trademark.

The solvent used for the transformation of the eucalyptus fiber is hard to pronounce so I don’t want to scare you with it – but it is non-toxic and biodegradable in addition to being an organic compound. This means that if it is dumped into nature by accident, it won’t (most likely) damage the environment. It is, by far, a better choice than sodium hydroxide to proceed with the dissolution of wood into a textile fiber.

The Lyocell process used for transformation of eucalyptus fiber is a closed-loop process which guarantees that 99% of the water and solvent used are recovered and reused again. This results in better water management and aims to preserve this natural resource we all need to live.

You might be surprised to learn that big brands like Zara and The Gap are increasing their use of TENCEL®. But for more local options check out Tamga Designs and Encircled (both also use organic cotton and/or bamboo), and Triarchy who use a TENCEL®/cotton blend made in a factory that uses 85% recycled water.

 

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton

Photo/ Encircled

Moving along to ORGANIC COTTON. 

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton

Photo/Unspalsh

Compared to its conventional counterpart, organic cotton scores much higher in terms of environmental impact. It does not require pesticides or fertilizers to grow, and it uses much less water.

According to a recent study conducted by Textile Exchange, organic cotton has the potential for environmental savings in several areas: it’s 46 percent less harmful to global warming, there’s 70 percent less acidification of land and water, the potential for soil erosion drops by 26 percent, surface and groundwater use falls 91 percent, and demand for energy could go down by as much as 62 percent.

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton

Photo/ Unsplash

Let’s take a closer look at water using the example of a cotton t-shirt. If made with conventional cotton, it would require 2,168 gallons of water compared to 186 for organic (a difference of 1,982 gallons). To make a pair of jeans, conventional cotton would take 9,910 gallons of water compared to 932 with organic (a savings of 8,978 gallons).

But the real water issue here is pollution. Runoff of pesticides, fertilizers, and minerals from cotton fields contaminates rivers, lakes, wetlands, and underground aquifers. These pollutants affect biodiversity directly by immediate toxicity or indirectly through long-term accumulation.

In addition to local fashion brands referenced earlier, larger apparel brands have been increasing their use of organic cotton. According to the Textile Exchange, the five biggest users of organic cotton, by volume are: C&A, H&M, Tchibo, Inditex and Nike. And in the years ahead, they anticipate those volumes will continue to grow. I hope so!

Related Content:

5 Clothing Recycling Mistakes You May Be Making

Who Made My Clothes? How To Be An Ethical Shopper

 

 

Sustainable Fabric Guide, Bamboo vs Lyocell vs Organic Cotton

 

 

kelly drennan

Kelly Drennan is the founder of Fashion Takes Action (FTA), Canada’s only non-profit organization devoted to sustainability in the fashion industry. She has received Treehugger’s Best in Green Award and been called one of the “30 most influential Canadian women to watch” by FLARE magazine.

No Comments Yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Follow us on Instagram!